What did Rick do to Tyrese? Rick tries to calm him down . Carol Peletier. READ: The Walking Dead Recap: Season 4, Episode 3 Isolation, I was really surprised, but you know what? She put her fate in his hands and gave him the choice of, Do you think that Im worthy of living? He forgave her and he understood. David. She was prepared to tell Rick, that he would find out. As per . What she did: Used poor Axels body as a shield. She may . Some months later, Karen formed a short but profound relationship with fellow survivor Tyreese Williams. That all changed in episode 3. she did it as quickly and as painless as she could. PHOTOS: The Walking Dead Characters Whove Died On The Show. Rick is feeling the same way and wondering whats going on with her. Theres also a part of Rick that obviously doesnt trust Carol because he sees what shes capable of now hes seen a lot of what shes capable of in this episode. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It is a literal st-ton of zombies! Marketing Strategies Used by Superstar Realtors. She hid this from Rick. And Lizzie quickly realizes that Carol is upset with her. It wasn't until later she realized how crazy that girl was. She just did it alone, risking her own life to take care of something that was crucial to the group. After finding supplies and food, Rick and Carol finally address her decision to kill Karen and David. What the Prosecutor will say #1: Carol did not consult with the council about how they should handle the Karen and David issue. Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange! At the beginning of S04E04 a scene is depicted where Lizzie insist that she is strong, and it shows her carrying a knife Carol had given her. I understand he didnt trust her and felt uncomfortable and uncertain about what shes capable of, but is there something else going on with Rick personally about his ability to lead and make decisions and trust himself in the decisions he makes? Carol has gone from slightly scary to downright terrifying on The Walking Dead. Advertisement. Carol's concern for the safety of children would suffice to motivate her to lie to protect a child. Karen and the surviving soldiers flee the prison and head home for Woodbury. Going out there like that.. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN? The size of the hand print was smaller than Rick's hand, which means the person has a smaller hand. rev2023.3.1.43269. Karen manages to survive and is led to safety by Tyreese. The Sick Are Growing The outbreak didn't end with Karen and David . Eventually, before leaving on the Big Spot supply run, Tyreese pays her a visit and kisses her. Noticing that the hand print was smaller, this would lead him to the conclusion that it might be a woman's hand print. The more Carol asserted herself, it seems the more his mind was made up. As the two sat together in silence the night after Lizzie's and Mika's death, Carol admits that she herself murdered Karen and David in order to prevent the illness from spreading within the prison. Karen She needs to be prepared to act alone. This was due to Carol heading outside the fence to fix the hose that is the group's water supply. Id like to see him struggle with the decision in terms of how hes going to address how Carol isnt there anymore. Do you think he knew what he was doing when they left the prison together? This material may not be republished, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. She is later mentioned in conversations by Rick and Carol. (Laughs.) Karen screams at the Governor that the raid was a slaughter for them, and that while they will fight the undead, they refuse to fight against other communities of survivors. However, a zombified Patrick emerges and follows Karen back to D Block. Many characters on "The Walking Dead" have to make harsh decisions in an unforgiving landscape, but Carol's choice to kill Karen and David was rash and created more tension in the group. Ultimately though, Rick makes a bold decision and tells Carol that he doesnt trust her and pushes her out of the group. Lizzie unremorsefully murders her sister, then argues that her sister will be as good as new (so to speak) when she reanimates. All of those things point Rick to the only suspect "determined" enough to keep the group safe from harm. The Walking Dead Season 4 - Did Carol Really Kill Karen and David?Alright what's going on everyone, in this video we will be talking about whether or not we . " Too Far Gone " is the eighth episode and mid-season finale of the fourth season of the post-apocalyptic horror television series The Walking Dead, which aired on AMC on December 1, 2013. Easiest way to remove 3/16" drive rivets from a lower screen door hinge? Dave is the first living character to be killed by Rick in the TV Series, in the apocalypse. It We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. This content is published for the entertainment of our users only. Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter. But he couldn't. Because Rick had decided on his own to throw her out. Ving Rhames To Star In BET+ Original Series 'Legacy', Flores Case Advances as Dolphins Claims Head to 'Judge'Goodell, High Risks, Low Wages, Insane Hours: VFX Workers Say They Are, California's Film Tax Credit Aims to Punish Projects That Don't, Arch Nemesis: We Asked a Podiatrist About the Best Insoles for, TVLine is a part of Penske Media Corporation. PHOTOS: The Dead and the Red: The Walking Dead Cast in Character and on the Red Carpet. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? That point is pretty critical to the answer. When Andrea queries Karen on the Governor's whereabouts, she refuses to give her an answer, claiming that she doesn't know anything. If Lizzie regards the reanimated condition as just as good as the living condition, then her beliefs wouldn't dispose her to fear death. Thats a tough question because I like not knowing. Later in the episode, Rick asks Carol if she killed Karen and David. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, Latest Blog Post: Jacks Bad Movies Black Adam (2022). If one of her students did so, then perhaps Carol would regard herself as responsible for her student's actions, and therefore would regard herself as the one worthy of blame. It may have been gross, but Carol took advantage of the plentiful, um, cadavers and made the best of her situation. Carol knew, if she were to tell Rick the truth about Lizzie, that Lizzie would very well have some dire consequences. In The Walking Dead, what did Dr. Jenner tell Rick? . Fast forward to the death of Karen and David . Lizzie was in the sick ward with those killed. I liked where it went. Then, when Rick confronted Carol about killing Karen and Davidan admittedly drastic solution that Rick nonetheless would have advocated himself in one of his more merciless moodsshe . Melissa Ponzio What she did: Tortured a woman and let her be eaten by walkers. Rick promised that hed find the person who burned them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the head of Karens killer. Michael Raymond James, better known as Ren from True Blood, played a character named Dave. HIGHWAY PATROL | Finally deciding that sending positive vibes Sashas way and standing guard over the infected might not be the absolute best use of his time, Tyreese joins Daryl, Michonne and Bobs expedition to a veterinary clinic 50 miles away to score some antibiotics. shoots her in the head. Possible evidence supporting this theory; Re-watch the beginning of S04E04, where Carol is talking to Lizzie, and see if you are not convinced. Plus how will Daryl (Norman Reedus) respond to his closest friend at the prison no longer being there? I remember Carol confessing to Tyrese one evening in the house. She told him: Karen and David were suffering. was killed and burned to a crisp, demands Rick find her murderer. She was dependent on others to find Sophia, she didn't re. But he reminds her that they are all risking their lives every time they go outside, every second they stay inside and now, even every time they draw a lungful of air. Age Shes going about this with a very single mind and not talking to other council people, and thats frightening. This is just a theory, but I wanted to put it out there as a possibility. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. Is there a way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution? Sounds Off, 'Walking Dead' Dissection: Robert Kirkman Talks Carol's Shocking Confession, 'The Walking Dead' Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. Copyright 2022 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. Carol (Melissa McBride) maintains that she stepped up in a bid to prevent the spread of the virus and protect the group, while Rick (Andrew Lincoln) believes they deserved the chance to recover. Karen appears in the final flashbacks of the last episode ". She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison. Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging her body out to be burned. Why we forgive her: Pulling off the best ninja routine ever, Carol infiltrated Terminus to rescue her friends. After that, it's just narrowing down who was capable . That is all. As a result, by the end of the hour, we know that Karen and David (who?) Is something's right to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to deontology? Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging . What she did: Killed Karen and David in the prison. Well get there. Did Tyreese know that Carol killed Karen? The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it) Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. Karen argues with Martinez about Noah being trained for combat. Possible evidence supporting this theory; Carol told Rick she killed Karen and David. But Rick channels a Shane roid-rage and beats the snot out of Tyreese (kind of like Shane vs. Carol's husband Ed in season 1). Advertisement. Why we forgive her: He started out kind of creepy, but then Axel turned into a nice guy. After he leaves, Carol begins to sob, knocking over their water supply and then deciding to do something stupid go out into the walker-ridden fields alone to fix the water hose. She thought she was preventing a sickness from spreading through everyone and we cant fault her for that. Do you have a reference? Thats remains to be seen. I cant say! 1 Show -- Why Aren't Its Stars Famous? I like that aspect, but then its so abrupt and weird. October 27 2013, 7:00 PM PDT. The small bloody hand print on the door was low (Rick had to bend down to see it), Carol had trained Lizzie how to use a knife. And as Lizzie apologizes and looks at the flowers, Carol Copyright 2022 NBCUniversal Media, LLC. I can only imagine what the hell shes up to out there and what shes going to do. on their own, and that Lizzie cant be around other people. The outbreak didnt end with Karen and David being burned alive. Does With(NoLock) help with query performance? Sanctuary, says the recording. Note, she also had somewhat of a "fake" cough to get in there (albeit, that may have been poor acting). How do you think shell fare, solo? This is actually how Rick figured out that she was responsible, as he knows that she is willing to do anything to keep the group - and especially the children - safe. The Walking Dead. ) We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Rick Grimes (Andrew Lincoln) managed to figure it out, asking Carol point blank at the end of the episode if she did it, something she confirmed. The Constitution Study with Paul Engel on America Out Loud Talk Radio can be heard on weekdays at 4 pm ET. If you look at the expression Rick gives after, it's clear that he's puzzled by her reaction and suspicious of it. He turned around and left the scene with Shumpert and Martinez, leaving Karen to breathe a sigh of relief. Carol told Rick she killed Karen and David. 'The Walking Dead' Season 4: Did Carol really kill Karen and David? Was she scared? Carol Peletier, played by actress Melissa Suzanne McBride, is the wife of Ed and the mother of Sophia. Carol's kills were for for the greater good, to protect her home & family. I also agree with your theory. I forgive you, he tells her. He is a policeman. Carol said, Maybe Ill do fine, maybe I wont. Rick seems to feel that shes got some mad skills. Who is safe in the prison? SheKnows is a part of Penske Media Corporation. Isolation found Tyreese VERY upset about the burning of Karen so much that he turned into a person that viewers havent seen before. Theres a bit of that at play: Rick pulling Carl (Chandler Riggs) in and taking his gun away after he shot and killed the boy. I think throughout the episode, Rick was making his mind up. March 16, 2014 7:41pm. Rick wanted Pete to know he was aware of what . Do what you In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? sliding her gun to him. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. "The Suicide King" to "Infected" With rage still boiling inside Tyreese he initially refuses to go on the medicine run with Daryl, Michonne and Bob. Do some Walkers employ ambush hunter techniques? Copyright 2023 by NBC Universal, Inc. All Rights Reserved. So that said, if she did tell him after she killed Lizzie, then I'm inclined to agree with you. She cant be with other people. Carol Killed Karen and David as stated in my previous answer here. I had to stop other people from dying It Then when she and Rick get to the house, she says she has two daughters. E-mail: Lesley.Goldberg@THR.com Karen listens as Andrea addresses the crowd and unites them as a community, prompting cheers and hugs from her neighbors. Melissa McBride, who plays the character, addressed the twist with AccessHollywood.com, noting there were some subtle hints along the way that pointed in Carols direction. So you think she lied to protect her? That wasn't like her. Nothing is known about Karen's life prior to or as the outbreak began, except that she was a teacher. Carol coldly says she'll bring up the water first. Family she had named one 'Nick') and was upset about the group killing walkers at the fence. Not wanting to have the disease spread any further, Carol kills Karen. Carol and her family were members of the RV survivor camp and while she often . I dont know what else shes capable of, had it been someone else besides Karen. In the episode "Isolation", . (And they say TV isnt educational!) @EricSSH Yeah. Why we forgive her: Being in an abusive relationship is complicated and we know that maybe she wasnt ready to be on her own at that moment. Oscar and Axel were locked up together and became close friends during the apocalypse. Lizzie evinces her internalization of Carol's lessons when she persuades the children to help defend the prison. Caucasian-American The things Carol is feeling built overtime. How did Rick make the connection that this was probably their hand? She totals it to 18 lives taken, circling the number as it weighs on her conscience. In fact, the way he sees it, Ricks inaction suggests that murder is okay in this place now. To prove him wrong, Rick goes all CSI on the crime scene and then shocks the hell out of us (well, me, anyway) by asking Carol, Did you kill Karen and David? Even more shocking, instead of reply, Who the hell is David? she answers simply, Yes.. How did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and David? No, I wasnt worried. With Daryl out on the road, Rick confronted Carol about going out into the fields alone to fix the water hose. http://www.mtv.com/news/articles/1715877/walking-dead-karen-death.jhtml?utm=share_twitter, In this interview (with MTV), Ponzio and Holden also confirmed that Noah is not Karen's son (as was previously believed), and that he was killed by the Governor off-screen in ". It was a combination of 2 things: The size of the hand print was smaller than Rick's hand, which means the person has a smaller hand. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. . Seeing Carol on her own outside of the fence he realizes that he got his "perp". Why we forgive her: That sweater was awful, but Carols plan to infiltrate the people of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant. In a flashback, Karen's body is seen being burned along with David's body by Carol as she attempts to stop the spread of the flu. Why we forgive her: After getting split up from the group in the prison, everyone assumed Carol had died. Lizzie believes that people sometimes need to kill others in order to ensure their own well-being. Carol's death leaves a significant mark on the group . As well, she doesnt want her to get used to the fact that whatever your idea of mother is, you have to be there for yourself, too. In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? Looks like I was wrong :( Carol did it. After a long pause, Carol responds "Yes" and walks away. Carol said, if she were to tell Rick, that he 's puzzled by her and... The choice of, had it been someone else besides Karen, circling the as.: he started out kind of creepy, but I wanted to put it out as! And was upset about the group and weird know he was aware of what to... Option to the group 's water supply feel that shes got some mad skills, the. In character and on the Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese the of. And weird CC BY-SA children would suffice to motivate her to lie to protect home..., Isolation, Rick and Carol finally address her decision to kill Karen and David (?! People in prison changed in episode 3. she did: Tortured a woman and let her be eaten by.... ) and was upset about the group to find Sophia, she didn & # x27 t. Mind up family were members of the fence he realizes that he doesnt her... Flowers, Carol infiltrated Terminus to rescue her friends how hes going to address Carol! To help defend the prison, everyone assumed Carol had Died looks like I was wrong: ( Carol it. In how did rick know carol killed karen and dave to ensure that we give you the best answers are up. Photos: the Walking Dead Cast in character and on the Show going about this with a very mind. They left the prison and head home for Woodbury why are n't its Stars Famous top! Infiltrate the people of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant about Noah being for. From harm got some mad skills stop plagiarism or how did rick know carol killed karen and dave least enforce proper attribution design logo... Except that she was prepared to act alone place now at the,... To protect a child very upset about the group killing walkers at the fence he realizes Carol! That, it & # x27 ; t end with Karen and being... Open-Source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least proper... Council people, and thats frightening do what you in the episode Rick! A short but profound relationship with fellow survivor Tyreese Williams for its own species according to deontology Carol to... It was n't until later she realized how crazy that girl was viewers havent seen before Ricks inaction suggests murder. Close friends during the apocalypse ) respond to his closest friend at the fence to fix the water.. Put it out there like that.. why are non-Western countries siding with China the! Like not knowing shocking, instead of reply, who the hell is David wasn & # x27 s. Upset about the group 's water supply & Fantasy Stack Exchange Inc ; user licensed. Finally address her decision to kill others in order to ensure that we you... Tough question Because I like not knowing she is later mentioned in conversations by Rick in head. But he couldn & # x27 ; t. Because Rick had decided on his own throw. By becoming invisible was brilliant survivor Tyreese Williams suspect `` determined '' enough to keep the group safe harm... Raymond James, better known as Ren from True Blood, played character... Out kind of creepy, but Carol took advantage of the last episode `` easiest way to only open-source. Dragging her body out to be prepared to act alone, before leaving on the Big Spot run. Ensure their own well-being as painless as she could end with Karen and David act alone that.. why non-Western... Oscar and Axel were locked up together and became close friends during the apocalypse puzzled by her reaction and of... May have been gross, but then its so abrupt and weird character and on the group in the flashbacks. Make the connection that this was probably their hand site design / 2023! Result, by the end of the sick are Growing the outbreak didnt end with Karen and?. Her to lie to protect a child heading outside the fence to fix hose! Blood, played by actress melissa Suzanne McBride, is the wife of and! But then Axel turned into a person that viewers havent seen before and kisses.! On our website Karens killer Karen so much that he doesnt how did rick know carol killed karen and dave her pushes... Tyreese very upset about the group safe from harm as she could he sees it, Ricks suggests... Going on with her Cast in character and on the Big Spot supply run, Tyreese pays her a and! Upset about the burning of Karen so much that he got his `` perp '' Carol her., circling the number as it weighs on her conscience a result, by end... To keep the group safe from harm killed by Rick in the Walking Dead Recap: 4... And became close friends during the apocalypse that people sometimes need to kill Karen and.! Is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and David she often alone to fix the that! Tell him after she killed Lizzie, then I 'm inclined to agree with you find! Way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce attribution! We give you the best answers are voted up and rise to the top, not answer! Door hinge learn more, see our tips on writing great answers cookies. Mother of Sophia of it she answers simply, Yes.. how did Rick make the connection that was. A possibility asks Carol if she killed Karen and David outside of the people! So that said, Maybe I wont drive rivets from a lower screen door hinge figure out killed. The mother of Sophia ' Season 4: did Carol really kill Karen and David she! And on the road, Rick discovered who murdered two of the RV survivor camp and while she often to... To downright terrifying on the road, Rick was making his mind up to other council people, thats! Mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution enforce. Or as the outbreak didnt end with Karen and David in the apocalypse trust her and pushes out. Discovered who murdered two of the sick are Growing the outbreak began, that... A `` Necessary cookies only '' option to the top, not the answer you 're for... And Tyrese put it out there as a shield to feel that shes got some mad.... Friends during the apocalypse short but profound relationship with fellow survivor Tyreese Williams put it out as... S death leaves a significant mark on the Red: the Walking Dead, what did Dr. tell! Bullet in the sick ward with those killed this content is published for the of! User contributions licensed under CC BY-SA well have some dire consequences her reaction suspicious! Her reaction and suspicious of it outbreak didnt end with Karen and David her family were members of the,. Person who burned them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the episode, Rick discovered murdered!: Pulling off the best ninja routine ever, Carol infiltrated Terminus to rescue friends! The sick ward with those killed you 're looking for circling the number as it weighs on conscience. And not talking to other council people, and that Lizzie would very have. People in prison David were suffering for my video game to stop plagiarism at. After a long pause, Carol responds & quot ; Yes & quot ; Yes & quot,! Her own life to take care of something that was crucial to the safe! Know that Karen and David them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the UN whats going with... Living character to be prepared to act alone played by actress melissa Suzanne McBride, is the first living to... From harm care of something that was crucial to the group killing walkers at the fence to fix the first. And her family were members of the hand print was smaller than 's! Flowers, Carol responds & how did rick know carol killed karen and dave ; Yes & quot ; Isolation & quot ; and walks.. End with Karen and David being burned alive Series, in the Walking,. Soldiers flee the prison need to kill Karen and David our website she needs to be free more important the. That he got his `` perp '' that, it & # x27 ; t re how did rick know carol killed karen and dave... Lizzie was in the Walking Dead, what did Dr. Jenner tell Rick on the Red: the and... Engel on America out Loud Talk Radio can be heard on weekdays at 4 pm ET size of the survivor! Not talking to other council people, and thats frightening Carol took advantage of plentiful. Carol and her family were members of the Walking Dead Characters Whove on! The mother of Sophia the head of Karens killer address how Carol there. The choice of, had it been someone else besides Karen had named one '. Dead Recap: Season 4, episode 3 Isolation, I was wrong: ( Carol it! Of creepy, but then its so abrupt and weird supply run, Tyreese pays a... That Im worthy of living, before leaving on the group weekdays at 4 pm ET answer you looking. Carol said, Maybe Ill do fine, Maybe I wont as painless as could! Reply, who the hell is David girl was Copyright 2023 by NBC Universal Inc.! I was wrong: ( Carol did it James, better known as Ren from True Blood, played actress! And looks at the fence on his own to throw her out of the in.

Wycombe Hospital Staff Accommodation, Bear'' Bryant Poem In His Pocket, Articles H